UK time is: 14:53:10
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Red card ref still contradictory

Referee Ray Olivier would appear to have condemned himself over his controversial sending off of Leicester City defender Patrick McCarthy on Saturday.

In the eyes of many fans his decision, so early in the match, ruined what was shaping up to be a cracking Championship game against Leeds and now Olivier has conceded that there may have been some doubt about its correctness.

Sendings off should be about what referees are sure of not what they think might have been the case. At least that would be common sense.

But Mr Olivier talked in riddles when he told the Leicester Mercury's Blue Army website: 'There was a shirt pull (fully accepted) and the judgement you make is on whether it 'clearly' denied the player a goalscoring opportunity. It is 'clear' in my mind that it was a red-card offence.'

And yet, told that City believe a covering defender (Richard Stearman) may have been able to take late preventative action he responded, 'Yes, may have been able too - 'may', it's a big word. I stand by my decision."

So there you have a referee saying it was 'clear' that it was a red card but conceding that Stearman 'may' have been able to intervene. In which case, how could it be 'clear' and how could it be correct?

Olivier remained as confusing in his own defence as he was in his officiating on Saturday, a performance which had Leeds boss Kevin Blackwell saying he was 'baffled' by many of the decisions.

'Just maybe,' he said sarcastically, 'those three (officials) were right and 25,000 people were wrong.'

Blackwell lamented the fact that managers are 'quite rightly' hammered in the media when things go wrong but managers aren't supposed to criticise referees if they have a poor game.

And that protection means that when this whole sorry business gets it's due official consideration the referee will probably get support, his doubtful, some would say stupid decision will probably be condoned, and Paddy McCarthy will serve a two-match suspension he 'may' not have deserved by the referees own apparent admission.

'May', dictionary definition 'expresssing uncertainty' is a wonderful word which is used by the best referees to avoid making any number of potentially far-reaching decisions in relatively innocuous circumstances when there is any element of doubt.

It may be a 'big' word but not as big as Saturday's referee. He knew better. His duty was 'clear' even if Stearman 'yes, may' have intervened.

And that was exactly like his performance generally - contradictory and repeatedly inconsistent.

Click Club Forums, click 100% Football for fans chat. Posters can now win monthly prizes for their contributions.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!


Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer:  Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday February 20 2006

Time: 12:32PM

Your Comments

One of the problems seems to be that in most instances these referees don't seem to be accountable for their dodgy decisions.
bluefox42
what really gets me about it is that he sent the wrong bloke off. His view of the incident was so good he didnt even know which player committed the offence. Olivier was a joke - start to finish - both sides would agree that.
nobby
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Articles

We are Premier League (Wednesday April 23 2014)

Stats: Bolton v Leicester (Tuesday April 22 2014)

Hammond Out To Be A Title Winner (Tuesday April 22 2014)

Pearson - Hails Discipline (Saturday April 19 2014)

Stats: Leicester v QPR (Saturday April 19 2014)

Leicester 1 QPR 0 - 19 April 2014 (Saturday April 19 2014)

Archived Articles

List All Vital Leicester  Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Leicester City 44 29 9 6 +37 96
2. Burnley 44 25 14 5 +34 89
3. Derby County 44 24 9 11 +30 81
4. Q.P.R. 44 22 10 12 +15 76
5. Wigan 43 20 10 13 +15 70
6. Reading 44 18 13 13 +12 67
7. Brighton 44 17 15 12 +12 66

Breaking League News

Cherries host Forest
Bournemouth : 24/04/2014 14:49:00
Prutton weighing up playing options
Sheff Wed : 24/04/2014 13:39:00
Owls have competition for Hull striker
Sheff Wed : 24/04/2014 13:34:00
Owls suffer double injury blow
Sheff Wed : 24/04/2014 13:28:00
Scout Focus: Leeds United
Birmingham : 24/04/2014 13:00:00
Madejski reveals 'slow progress' in owner search
Reading : 24/04/2014 13:00:00
Freedman: I'm Building A Team
Bolton : 24/04/2014 11:46:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Bolton MotM
Suggested By:  Svens
Schmeichel 0%
De Laet 0%
Konchesky 0%
James 0%
Wasilewski 0%
Morgan 0%
Mahrez 100%
Drinkwater 0%
Nugent 0%
King 0%
Knockaert 0%
Sub - Wood 0%
Sub - Dyer 0%
Sub - Hammond 0%